Real New York
Shoe shining underneath the Citicorp Center. 2:15 PM. Photo: JH.
The cover of the invitation was a sketch of Bobby Short by his old friend Joe Eula, leaning against his piano with his dog looking up at him. Inside it read:Yanna and Warren Avis, Larry Chrysler, Susan Fales-Hill and Aaron Hill, Alex Hitz, Casey Ribicoff, Lisa and David Schiff, Lynn and Oscar Wyatt and Christina Wyeth ... Invite you to join them for Dinner and Dancing to Celebrate the Birthday of Bobby Short, Sunday, the Twelfth of September at Half After Seven In the Evening, The Rainbow Room Rockefeller Center. Black tie.”

The cover of the invite (illustration by Joe Eula) which reads "Because it's Bobby's Birthday."
It was birthday number 80. There were, at last count, 180 guests. Peter Duchin played during the long cocktail hour and Bobby’s band played through dinner. Bobby Short is a real Mr. New York. The boy from Danville, Illinois, who calls himself a “saloon singer,” who first started playing professionally when he was eight years old, settled here (after Los Angeles and Paris) in the mid 50s, early 60s, and he’s been a mainstay of Manhattan nightlife (thirty-five years at the Café Carlyle) ever since.

When I was a young kid I used to wish I could grow up to be another Bobby Short. Just think, sitting there at the grand, rapping out those Cole Porter tunes, Kern, Arlen, Gershwin, Coward, you-name-it and singing your heart out, and getting paid for it. Alas, although I can carry a tune (and used to remember all the words), I’m a banger on the pianer.

Whereas Mr. Short is ... the quintessence, the top, the Colisseum, the Louvre Museum. My favorite album of his – and I’ve got quite a few of them – is the double one he did with Mabel Mercer at Town Hall in the late 1960s. The two of them, Short and Mercer (he then the baby, she by then sainted of all the saloon singers – Sinatra would have agreed too), singing separately and together and ending the show with Cy Coleman’s “Here’s To Us, (my darling, my dear; here’s to us tonight. Not for what may happen next year, for it might not be nearly as bright ....)” Open the Dom or the Cristal or the Veuve Cliquot and sing out Louise.

While we’re on the subject of albums, there’s the composer songbooks – Bobby Loves Cole, Bobby Loves Noel, Bobby Loves Rodgers and Hart, Bobby is k-k-k-k-krazy for Gershwin. All brilliant, all vintage, all that stuff of New York that gets under your skin from the time you were a kid living somewhere out there longing to be a part of the Big Town. Mr. New York, and it’s all yours.

So, seventy-two years after his first gig – and then he was on the road playing the joints across America by the time he was twelve, the child prodigy of the jazz babies, (he can’t read a note, they say; but he can literally play anything!) delighting the masses and the greats (like Fats Waller) who shared their wisdom with the boy – he’s still at it.

At Bobby’s table, among others, were Jean Bach, his oldest friend in New York, and the great Jessye Norman who also shares Bobby’s birthday (September 15) and who sang for him acapella “Our Love Is Here To Stay.” Barbara Carroll, who has known Bobby for almost fifty years (Barbara opens again at the Alguonquin on September 19th) played and sang, and then accompanied Julie Wilson who sang Jimmy van Heusen and Burton Lane’s “But Beautiful” (“Love is funny or it’s sad; or it’s quiet or it’s mad. It’s a good thing or it’s bad, But Beautiful ...").

Bobby's birthday cake
Then Tony Bennett gave a rousing and inimitably sophisticated “They All Laughed,” followed by Cy Coleman doing a medley of his tunes and ending with the Carolyn Leigh collaboration, “The Best Is Yet To Come.” There was a cake (in the picture), the first page of Cole Porter’s “You’re The Top”), tributes from his old friend (and one of the hosts) Lisa Schiff, as well as from a newer friend, also one of the hosts, Alex Hitz. The man just sat there taking it all in, bright-eyed, smiling face, nary a word (or a tune).

I was watching and listening, taking it all in while thinking how this man at the center of this most glamorous fete started out life in a very different America, a poor middle America, in the midst of the Depression. He was an eight-year-old working to help his mother support her family. It was a rough life of show business that he had to endure on the road, a rough life for anyone in those days, and an even unimaginably rougher life for a child of color faced with the harsher realities and ancient American laws of bigotry, far far away from the safety and comfort of his mother’s house.

Above: Baby Bobby, 1926-27. Below: Bobby, circa 2000.
I was thinking how the young boy, blessed with an unflagging enthusiasm and a photographic memory, armed with a talent that was just there from the moment he first sat down at the keyboard (about age three or four), along with a god-given charm and curiosity, a drive and an ambition to learn — not only about his music but about life and culture — and a willingness and a joie de vivre; I was thinking how with these gifts he made a great and long career bringing joy to hundreds of thousands, maybe millions down through the decades, and how that has kept him, protected him, rewarded him and supported him throughout his long and abundant life.

I was thinking how on this night, high above the town that he epitomizes, that once-upon-a-time little boy from 1034 Robinson Street, Danville, Illinois, now listed in the New York Social Register, was surrounded by scores of devoted friends, young, old, rich, not so rich, famous, not famous, all adoring fans, so pleased to be in his company, to share his largesse; how proud his mother would have been. The stuff of dreams. And of dreams come true.

Among the guests: Ahmet and Mica Ertegun, Dominick Dunne, Agneta Marian, Tom Fallon (who also shares the September 15 birthday), Ashley Schiff with Rusty O’Kelly, Dina Merrill and Ted Hartley, Aileen Mehle, Anne Slater and John Cahill, Geoffrey Holder and Carmen de Lavallade, Ellin Saltzman, Helen O’Hagan, Nancy Hamon, Brooke Hayward Duchin, Hugh Bush, Kay Pick, Liz Smith, Joel Schumacher, Doug Cramer, Cynthia McFadden, Peter Rogers, Joel Grey, Margaret Whiting, Peter and Jane Marino, Tom Teeple, Rosemarie Stack, Thelma Golden, Abby and Robert Kimball (Mr. Kimball is the great archivist of American musical composers, particularly Cole Porter), Elizabeth Peabody, Gerry Stutz, Marti Stevens, Evelyn Cunningham, Joe Eula Mildred Roxborough, Michael Cannon, Ray Gestal, Pamela Fiori and Colt Givner, Lowery Sims, Dwight Owsley, Sam and Judy Peabody, Frank Bowling, Brad and Amy Fine Collins, Preston Young, Marguarite Littman, Ruth and Skitch Henderson. HAPPY BIRTHDAY BOBBY.
Agneta Marian
Gail Lumet Buckley
Jean Bach and Bobby Short
Joe Eula and Ellin Saltzman
Kay Pick
Kevin Buckley
Wendy Vanderbilt and Dr. Frank Perdito
Tony Bennett
Liz Spahr
Lenny Kravitz
Rusty O'Kelley and Ashley Schiff
Alex Hitz and Rosemarie Stack
Joel Grey and Peter Rogers
Tom Fallon and Margaret Whiting
Lynn Wyatt and Ted Hartley
Diana Quasha
Kitty Carlisle Hart
Barbara Carroll
Julie Wilson
Bobby's band
Mica Ertegun and Dominick Dunne
Hugh Bush and Liz Smith
Jessye Norman, who also shares Bobby’s birthday, (September 15) singing “Our Love Is Here To Stay.”

Monday morning. A beautiful day in New York, I went down to the Tents at Bryant Park for a scheduled ten o’clock Oscar de la Renta show. Traffic was hard to bear crossing midtown. At ten after ten I jumped out of the cab at 39th and Fifth and hoofed it over to Sixth and Fortieth, hoping that I’d make it before the lights went down and they stripped the runway of the plastic cover. No problem. Inside the still covered runway was a mass of paparazzi, masses and masses, congested, clogged in a narrow space of about twelve feet in length, holding up everyone who needed to get by to their seat. And why? Ashley Olsen. Or one of the Olsen twins (the one who didn’t go into rehab – you fill in the blanks), and Jessica Simpson.

Oh yes, there was also The Donald and Melania, and only a minute away wearing a Borsalino and white pantsuit, Miss Joan Collins. But this was the Ashley and Jessica moment and the photographers and the vidcams and the reporters couldn’t get enough of ... What? You tell me. Meanwhile, about ten-thirty or so, with the help of Mr. de la Renta’s famously brilliant and charming sales impresario – the man who delivers high fashion (honest-to-god) therapy for many of the most famous and stylish women of the world (not to mention many of the richest), Boaz Mazor — the rest of us found our assigned seats. I turned on the Digital, the lights went down, the music came up, and out they came, the fashion ponies. I got most of the numbers, give or take a dozen or so that didn’t come out well.
Under the tents at Bryant Park
Jessica Simpson
Dana Schiff and Di Petroff
Lynn Wyatt and Emilia Fanjul
A Jimmy Choo moment

Have you subscribed to New York Social Diary?
Enter your Email address and click on subscribe to receive emails about the activities of NYSD. It's free!
Email address:



September 14, 2004, Volume IV, Number 144
Photographs by DPC/NYSD.com

Email
A
Friend



Click here
for NYSD Contents




 

© 2006 David Patrick Columbia & Jeffrey Hirsch/NewYorkSocialDiary.com